Mailing List Archive

Mailing List: techdiver

Banner Advert

Message Display

Date: Tue, 11 Aug 1998 20:05:40 +1000
To: wrolf@co*.ne*
From: bdi <bdi@wh*.ne*>
Subject: Re: CONTINUOUS REBREATHER DEATHS was Re: Death was a Bigot
Cc: kirvine@sa*.ne*, Martin Parker <mjp@ap*.av*.co*.uk*>,
At 01:08 AM 11/08/1998 -0400, Wrolf Courtney wrote:
>Katherine V. Irvine wrote:
>> 
>> Scatssa - you need to wake up. The thing does not work, it is a copy of
>> a copy of a failed design that has long since been discovered and
>> corrected.
>
>Which failed design does the Buddy Inspiration rebreather copy?
>
>> There have been SIX incidents REPORTED, THREE DEATHS
>
>I am only aware of five.  Which is the sixth?  (See
>http://www.concentric.net/~Wrolf/#Inspiration for my list.)
>
>> You need to start telling the truth. These machines
>> have another fifty horror stories of failed electronics, they are
>> basiscly unusable by those who bought them, and it is time they all came
>> forward and threw this crowd under the bus .
>
>You definitely know something I don't.  Fifty cases of failed
>electronics!  Do you have a source in the RMA department there?  I'll
>kiss your A** in Macy's store window if you'll share (I know a manager
>there with the key!)
>
>On a separate note:
>
>Martin, you are best off with a UK jurisdiction.  Libel laws in England
>& Wales are much more true to the original - the only real defense is
>that the statements were true as written. 

Wrolf, I like you. I like your web site. It does all of us
a big favour in providing a single access point to some 
fascinating and useful information about advanced diving.

But early on you seem to have picked sides against one of
the better sources of real diving information on the internet
and, whether you like it or not, the director of the best
advanced exploratory diving outfit the world has seen.

I enjoyed your little prose foray into the NY legal scene. 
I even managed to read most of your gratuitous 'advice' piece 
to Martin Parker (how come he asked YOU?) about which law 
firm he should hire if he wants to use the legal system of your 
weird and wacky country to attack George, even though your 
summary of the British legal system was cockeyed and the threat 
implied in your piece was cack-handed in the extreme.

But I think you should recognise the fact that at least five near 
death experiences and three actual deaths from the first 120 
Inspiration rebreathers does not make for an enviable product 
launch.

Imagine if every 24th Jaguar car almost killed its passengers,
or if every 24th BAC airliner gave its passengers a near death
thrill and actually took half of them out in the process.

Tell me how many deaths you will need to see on the Inspiration
before YOU recognise that the concept, design and/or components
are flawed?

And on another note, even though you have obvious trouble with
the presentation, you will find that George's advice, unlike 
Martin Parker's rebreather, has never killed anyone.

best regards, & keep up the good work.

billyw


--
Send mail for the `techdiver' mailing list to `techdiver@aquanaut.com'.
Send subscribe/unsubscribe requests to `techdiver-request@aquanaut.com'.

Navigate by Author: [Previous] [Next] [Author Search Index]
Navigate by Subject: [Previous] [Next] [Subject Search Index]

[Send Reply] [Send Message with New Topic]

[Search Selection] [Mailing List Home] [Home]